After three years of being the agreeable, invisible girlfriend to my tech CEO boyfriend, Edward, I finally left him. Then Brody Frazier, his charming rival, swept into my life, determined to use me to get under Edward's skin.
But at a tech gala, Edward cornered me, publicly declaring his love and flashing a "promise ring" he claimed he'd bought for me weeks ago.
He did this right after his high school crush, Jeannette, announced their engagement, and right before he accused me of humiliating him.
He insisted his feelings for Jeannette were a "youthful fantasy" and that I was his "anchor," his "stability." He said he loved me.
But I remembered the truth. I remembered the small, hand-carved wooden bird he'd once made.
A gift he'd had me send to Jeannette years ago, along with a love note he dictated himself.
And I knew his desperate confession wasn't love. It was damage control.
Chapter 1
The silence after I finally cut ties with Edward, after three years of feeling like I was living in a ghost story, was supposed to be freeing. Instead, it was deafening. Then Brody Frazier walked into my life, a whirlwind of charm and a transparent agenda, trying to use me to get under Edward's skin. And for the first time in what felt like forever, I wasn't just seen; I was noticed.
Brody had been relentless in his pursuit. Not in a creepy way, but persistent. Like a golden retriever with a new favorite toy. He' d shown up at my office, sent flowers, left ridiculous, over-the-top voicemails. For weeks, I' d deflected. Ignored. Politely declined.
But he was good. Too good.
"Just one coffee," he'd pleaded yesterday, his voice a smooth rumble through the phone. "Thirty minutes. If you hate it, you never have to see me again. Promise."
He didn' t sound like he believed that promise, and neither did I.
I sighed, staring at my reflection in the office window. "Fine," I'd said, surprising myself.
His immediate, triumphant "Yes!" had made me smile despite myself.
Now, sitting across from him in a bustling cafe, I realized my mistake. He wasn' t just charming; he was captivating. His eyes, the color of warm honey, held a mischievous glint as he leaned forward.
"I' m going to make you forget Edward Atkins ever existed," he declared, his voice dropping to a theatrical whisper. He wasn't being subtle about his intentions for Edward, but for me, it felt... intense.
A nervous flutter stirred in my stomach. I knew his game. Everyone knew Brody wanted to outshine Edward in everything, and now that extended to me. But his conviction, the sheer force of his presence, was disarming.
My coffee arrived, steaming hot. I wrapped my hands around the mug, more for comfort than warmth.
"Cold?" he asked, already shrugging out of his designer jacket. "You look a little pale."
"No, I'm fine," I said quickly, maybe too quickly. "It's just... a little chilly in here."
He ignored my protest, draping the expensive fabric over my shoulders. It smelled faintly of something musky and expensive, a stark contrast to the sterile scent of my own clothes.
"You should really take better care of yourself, Allyson," he murmured, his gaze soft. "Edward never noticed when you shivered, did he?"
A sharp pang went through me. He was right. Edward wouldn't have noticed. He rarely noticed anything beyond the flickering numbers on his stock ticker.
I pulled the jacket tighter, a small, involuntary movement. "Edward was busy," I mumbled, feeling the familiar need to defend him, even now. It was a habit I was trying to break.
Brody scoffed, a low, dismissive sound. "Busy building his empire, I suppose. Some empires aren't worth the cost." He paused, his eyes searching mine. "Or the collateral damage."
I didn't respond, just took a long sip of my coffee. The warmth spread through me, both from the drink and the jacket. It felt... strange. Unfamiliar.
"It's a nice jacket," I finally said, the safest compliment I could offer.
Brody beamed, genuinely pleased. "See? I told you I'd be better at this. Edward probably bought you a gift card or some generic tech gadget he got a bulk discount on."
The words hit harder than they should have. My mind flashed back to my last birthday with Edward. He' d given me a new smart speaker. "To help you manage your tasks more efficiently," he'd said, his tone devoid of warmth. Before that, a gift card to a department store. Always practical. Never personal.
I remembered the time I had a terrible flu, shivering under three blankets, my head pounding. Edward had been in the next room, glued to his laptop. He' d asked if I needed anything, but his eyes never left the screen. When I weakly asked for a glass of water, he'd sighed, stood up, and retrieved it, placing it on my nightstand with a clinical detachment. No lingering touch, no checking my fever. Just the swift, efficient execution of a request.
Brody' s jacket, warm and scented, felt like a foreign object. A gesture I hadn't realized I was starved for.
"I'm glad you like it," Brody said, pulling me back to the present. His smile was so wide it crinkled the corners of his eyes. "So, about our date on Saturday, still good for the art gallery?"
I hesitated. "I haven't been to an art gallery in years," I admitted, a little embarrassed. "Edward always said it was a waste of time."
Brody' s expression hardened for a split second, then softened. "Then it's perfect," he said, tapping a finger on the table. "A new experience. Something Edward would never appreciate." He scribbled something on a napkin. "I've made a note of your 'lack of art gallery experience.' Don't worry, I'll enlighten you. And I'm doing a much better job already than Atkins ever did."
I watched him, a quiet observer. He was so transparent, his motives laid bare. Yet, there was something endearing about his earnestness. He genuinely seemed to want to make an impression. Edward had never bothered. Edward had seen me as a convenient fixture, a stable presence to return to after his long, demanding days. He'd never really seen me at all.
"So, what do you think he's really after?" I asked myself, my gaze lingering on Brody's enthusiastic face. Edward, with his calculating mind, had probably only pursued me because I represented stability, a lack of drama, a blank canvas he could, perhaps, mold. He'd never truly wanted the complexity of me.
A comfortable silence settled between us, or perhaps it was just the quiet hum of the cafe. Brody was still smiling, oblivious to the storm brewing in my thoughts. He was a distraction, a bright, chaotic splash of color in the muted palette Edward had painted my life with. And maybe, just maybe, that was exactly what I needed.
"Okay," I finally said, meeting his gaze. "Saturday sounds good."
"Wow!" I exclaimed, my voice echoing a little too loudly in the otherwise hushed art gallery. A colossal abstract sculpture, made of twisted metal and shimmering glass, dominated the center of the room. It looked like a storm frozen in time. "It' s... it' s absolutely wild!"
Brody laughed, a genuine, joyful sound that cut through the polite murmurs of other patrons. He stood beside me, his head tilted back, admiring the piece with an intensity I hadn't expected. His initial, transparent motive for being here felt a million miles away.
"Wild is a good word for it," he agreed, his eyes sparkling. "It' s got guts. It' s not trying to be anything other than what it is."
I felt a warmth spread through me, a feeling of pure, unadulterated excitement I hadn't let myself feel in years. My ex-boyfriend, Edward, would have called it "pretentious" or "a frivolous waste of resources." He would have dissected its market value, not its soul.
"I can't believe I've never experienced anything like this before," I murmured, a sudden vulnerability in my voice. "It' s... overwhelming in the best possible way." A tear pricked the corner of my eye, a physical manifestation of the emotion bubbling up inside me.
Brody noticed immediately. He didn't ask what was wrong. He simply reached out, gently taking my hand. His thumb rubbed soothing circles on my skin. He didn't say anything, just let me feel.
After a moment, he squeezed my hand. "It's good to feel things, Allyson," he said, his voice soft, almost a whisper. "Really feel them. You're allowed to."
I looked at him, my vision still a little blurry from the unshed tears. He was watching me with an expression of quiet triumph, like a scientist observing a successful experiment. It was a strange mix of genuine care and calculated satisfaction.
A part of me, the part that was still guarded, knew he was enjoying this. He'd seen a genuine emotional reaction, and in his strategic mind, that was a win. He cares, I thought, a tiny voice in my head, and he' s thrilled that I' m letting him see it.
"You know," he continued, still holding my hand, "when someone feels safe enough to show you their raw emotions, it means you're doing something right. It means they trust you." He said it with such earnest conviction, I almost believed he was purely focused on me.
I pulled my hand back gently, a small smile touching my lips. "You know a lot about art, for someone who pretends to be just a rich kid with too much time on his hands."
He shrugged, a playful glint returning to his eyes. "My dad had me dragged to these things since I was old enough to walk. Said it was 'cultural immersion.' I mostly just snuck snacks and drew caricatures of the stuffy patrons." He gestured towards a massive, brightly colored canvas that looked like a child's finger painting. "But sometimes, you find a gem."
I stared at the painting, then back at him. "You draw?"
He looked surprised, a genuine blush rising on his cheeks. "Uh, yeah. Sometimes. Nothing serious." He was suddenly shy, a side of him I hadn't seen yet.
"Show me sometime," I found myself saying, the words leaving my mouth before I could second-guess them.
He grinned. "Definitely."
As we walked through another hall, past oil paintings and intricate sculptures, I felt a new kind of ease with him. A comfortable quiet joined the playful banter. It wasn't just the art that was opening me up; it was Brody. He was observant, attentive, even when his motivations were still cloudy.
I remembered Edward' s dismissive attitude towards anything that wasn't directly related to his work. Edward was brilliant, a self-made tech CEO. He' d built Atkins Technologies from the ground up, starting with nothing but a fierce intellect and an even fiercer ambition. He' d come from a humble background, clawing his way up, always driven by the fear of falling back into obscurity.
"My first big idea got laughed out of every VC meeting," Brody admitted, as if reading my thoughts about ambition. "They called it 'naive,' 'unscalable.' Said I was just a trust fund baby playing with daddy's money." He kicked at an invisible pebble on the polished floor. "I tried to prove them wrong, pushed myself too hard. It wasn't pretty. I crashed and burned pretty spectacularly for a while there."
He finally looked at me, a wry smile on his face. "That's when I learned that sometimes, you have to play a different game."
"And what game is that?" I asked, already knowing the answer.
"The one where Edward Atkins loses," he said, his honey eyes hardening just a fraction. "And where Brody Frazier wins. That's why I'm here, Allyson. To get under his skin. To make him realize what he lost. You're the key to that."
I almost laughed. Edward, with his unflappable composure, his iron will. He wouldn't even notice. He was too busy battling other tech titans, too focused on the next big acquisition. Brody, for all his charm and resources, hadn't seen the real Edward. The kind of Edward who could make you feel like you were shrinking into nothingness.
"You really think you can rattle Edward?" I asked, a hint of skepticism in my voice. Edward was a concrete wall. Brody was a charming breeze.
Brody gave me a confident smirk. "He's not as invincible as he pretends to be. Everyone has a soft spot. Or a glaring weakness." He paused, his gaze sweeping over me. "And I think I just found his."
We stopped for a moment at the gift shop, and Brody insisted on buying me a small, intricately carved wooden bird. "A reminder of today," he said, pressing it into my palm.
"Thank you," I said, my fingers closing around the smooth wood. It was a thoughtful gesture. The kind Edward would never make.
"So," he said, as we stepped out into the cool evening air, "about that Edward Atkins. You two kept things pretty quiet, didn't you? Barely saw you at any of his big corporate events."
I shrugged. "That was his preference. He said it was better for my privacy, and less distracting for him."
"Right. Privacy," Brody muttered, his tone dripping with sarcasm. "Or maybe he just didn't want to explain why he was with a woman who actually had a personality." He narrowed his eyes, a thoughtful frown on his face. "Actually, I remember seeing you at one of his company holiday parties, years ago. You were wearing this... handmade silver pendant? A crescent moon with a tiny star."
I blinked, surprised. "I... I don't remember that."
"Oh, it was definitely you," he insisted. "I distinctly recall thinking it was a strange choice for someone like Edward. Too... unique for his taste." He looked at me, a flicker of something unreadable in his gaze. "He was talking to someone else, I think, about it. Bragging, almost. Like it was some kind of trophy."
The silver pendant. I tried to conjure an image of it, but my memory was hazy. Edward' s gifts were always so generic. A designer scarf. An expensive watch. Things he could buy off a list. They were transactional, symbols of his success, not expressions of affection. They lacked any real personal touch, any hint that he'd thought about me.
But there was one exception. A small, handcrafted wooden bird, carved by him in a moment of rare, uncharacteristic sentimentality years ago. A gift for someone else.
Brody's honey eyes flashed with something akin to jealousy. "He might have been bragging, but he clearly didn't appreciate what he had. He certainly didn't deserve you, Allyson. I can promise you, I'll do better."
I gave him a noncommittal hum, my thoughts still snagged on the silver pendant and the wooden bird. His certainty was appealing, but also a little unnerving. I knew his game, and I was playing along, yet sometimes his conviction felt too real.
We walked aimlessly for a while, the evening breeze ruffling my hair. We passed a small carnival setup, complete with flashing lights and the distant, tinny music of a merry-go-round.
"Look!" Brody exclaimed, his adult veneer momentarily dissolving into boyish delight. He pointed to a shooting gallery. "I'm a crack shot. I'll win you something."
He was already pulling me towards it, his enthusiasm infectious. My heart gave a little flutter. Edward would have walked right past, maybe commented on the inefficiency of carnie games as an investment.
"You really don't have to," I said, but a part of me, a small, neglected part, wanted him to.
He ignored me, already handing over a crisp bill to the tattooed attendant. "Pick your prize, Allyson. Anything you want."
I watched him, a strange mix of apprehension and genuine curiosity coiling in my stomach. He was so focused, his brow furrowed in concentration as he aimed the rifle. A thrill, unexpected and potent, shot through me. This was new. This felt different.
"Be careful," I warned, a sudden image of something going wrong flashing in my mind.
He was too engrossed, too intent on hitting the target, to hear me. He fired, and a plastic duck toppled over. He let out a whoop of victory, then turned to me, his face alight with pride.
"See? Thought I lost my touch. What do you want, Allyson? The giant teddy bear? The ridiculous oversized banana?"
I smiled, shaking my head. "Just pick something small. Anything."
He chose a fluffy, bright blue stuffed animal, a caricature of a monster with one large eye. He presented it to me with a flourish.
"Here you go," he said, puffing out his chest. "My winnings. For you. You know, I could probably buy all these prizes if I wanted to, but there' s no fun in that. The chase, the effort, that's what makes it worthwhile."
Time seemed to melt into a blur of laughter and easy conversation with Brody. He showed me a side of the city I'd never seen, took me to hole-in-the-wall restaurants, and even convinced me to try a ridiculously spicy street food that left my mouth burning but my spirit exhilarated.
In the weeks that followed, Brody became a constant, bright presence. He listened. Really listened. He remembered details I' d casually mentioned months ago. He brought me my favorite coffee when he knew I had an early start. He championed my ideas at work, pushing me to apply for a specialized training program that Edward would have seen as a distraction.
And I got in. The acceptance letter arrived on a Tuesday, a rainy, miserable Tuesday.
I was soaked to the bone, getting out of a cab, when I saw him. Brody, standing under the awning of my apartment building, clutching a dripping umbrella. He was soaked too, his hair plastered to his forehead.
"What are you doing here?" I asked, my voice a little breathless.
He grinned, a flash of white in the gloom. "I knew you'd get it. Had a feeling. Wanted to be here when you got the news." He held out a small, meticulously wrapped package. "Celebration gift."
Inside was a delicate, handcrafted wooden bird, similar to the one he'd won for me at the carnival, but this one was painted in vibrant blues and greens, like a hummingbird.
"Allyson, this is beautiful," I said, genuinely touched. "But you shouldn't have."
"Nonsense," he said, his eyes shining. "You deserve nice things. Thoughtful things. Things that show someone actually sees you." He leaned in, his voice dropping. "It's what I do best. Unlike some people."
His competitive streak was still there, but it was interwoven with something else now, something warmer.
"I actually made you something too," I confessed, suddenly shy. I reached into my purse and pulled out a small, intricately folded origami crane. It wasn't much, but I'd spent hours on it, choosing the paper, perfecting the folds.
Brody took it from me like it was made of solid gold. His eyes widened, and a genuine, unselfconscious smile spread across his face. "You made this? For me?" He looked so genuinely thrilled, it melted something tight inside me. "Allyson, this is incredible. No one has ever made me anything."
"It's just paper," I mumbled, suddenly embarrassed by its simplicity.
"It's not 'just paper'," he corrected, his voice firm. "It's from you. It's thoughtful. It's personal." He carefully tucked it into his jacket pocket, right over his heart. "This is staying right here."
A week later, he invited me to a tech gala. "It's huge," he said. "All the big players will be there. Edward included." His eyes held that familiar glint of strategic mischief.
"Okay," I said, a shrug escaping me. I found myself looking forward to it, not for the drama, but for the chance to spend another evening with Brody.
We arrived at the glittering ballroom, a symphony of chandeliers and hushed conversations. I'd opted for a simple, elegant black dress, wanting to avoid any unnecessary attention. Brody, as always, was impeccably dressed, a vision in a tailored suit.
He held my hand as we navigated the throng, introducing me to people with genuine pride. I felt a sense of belonging I hadn't realized I was missing. We found a quiet corner near the buffet. I picked up a delicate pastry, taking a bite. It was sweet, with a hint of citrus.
"Try this," I said, holding out a piece to Brody. He leaned in, taking it from my fingers, his lips brushing against mine for a fleeting second. A spark, small but distinct, ignited.
It was then that I saw him. Edward Atkins. He stood near the entrance, a commanding presence even amidst the glittering crowd. And beside him, laughing, her arm linked through his, was Jeannette Slater. The Jeannette Slater.
My breath hitched. Edward' s high school crush, the one he' d idealized for years. The one I knew he' d never truly gotten over. She was even more stunning in person, a vibrant, vivacious woman with a cascade of blonde hair and a dazzling smile.
Edward' s eyes, cold and sharp as ever, swept across the room. And then they landed on me.
His gaze locked with mine, a flicker of surprise, then something else I couldn't quite decipher. Recognition. A jolt went through me, an unpleasant electric shock.
Brody, feeling the sudden tension in my hand, looked up. He followed my gaze. His eyes narrowed.
"Well, well, well," Brody purred, a predatory smile spreading across his face. "Speak of the devil." He squeezed my hand, then pulled me closer, wrapping an arm possessively around my waist. He leaned down, his lips brushing my ear, his voice low and dangerous. "Let's make this worthwhile, shall we?"
I knew what he was doing. I knew his objective. And yet, I didn't pull away. I just watched Edward, his eyes boring into me, and thought, He won't care. He never did.
But Edward's gaze didn't waver. It lingered, sharp and intense, not on Brody's arm, but on me. And for some reason, that made my skin prickle. Not with fear, but with an unfamiliar unease.