The Forbidden Puck: The Coach's Daughter is Off Limits

Chapter One: To Babysit Her?

Ray's Pov

I should have said no.

The second Professor Hartwell asked me to babysit his daughter, I should have walked out. But I didn't. I just sat there, in the worn leather chair across from his desk, trying to figure out what game we were playing.

I'd been in his office plenty of times. Usually, it was because I'd missed a morning skate or my grade in his Econ class was slipping. This was different. The door was shut, the noise from the hockey arena was just a distant hum, and he was looking at me like I was a play he was drawing up.

"She does not know I am asking you," he said. His voice was low. He slid a photograph across the polished wood.

It felt slimy. Like a secret handshake or a backroom deal. Not a favor from a coach to his team captain.

I looked down.

The girl in the picture was laughing. Her head was tilted back, her dark hair swinging. She wasn't just pretty. She was the kind of pretty that made you stare. My eyes stuck on the curve of her smile, then drifted down to her hip before I jerked them back up.

Sexy. The word popped into my head before I could stop it.

No wonder she needed a babysitter.

"Sir," I said, clearing my throat. It felt tight. "I don't think I get it. What are you asking me to do?"

"You're the captain, Ray Collins. You know what happens after games. The parties. The guys."

He said the word guys like it was something dirty. "My daughter has decided to join the team as a photographer this semester. I need someone to make sure she does not get... distracted."

"She's an adult," I said carefully. What I wanted to say was, This is crazy. But I bit the words back. I needed this man. I needed the letter he could write for me.

"She is nineteen," he corrected, leaning back. His chair creaked. "She has spent her entire life in classrooms and libraries. She does not understand the world. She does not understand what boys that age want from her."

And there it was. The real ask.

"You want me to babysit her."

"I want you to watch out for her. Treat her like you would a sister. If you saw your sister at a party with a bunch of young men who only want one thing, what would you do?"

I didn't have a sister. "I'd probably tell her to have fun and make good choices," I said. It came out with a little bit of an edge.

The air in the office got colder. He didn't like my tone.

"I will make it worth your time." He leaned forward again, elbows on the desk. "Five hundred dollars. Every week. Cash. And that recommendation letter for graduate school you asked me about? Consider it done."

Fuck.

The word was a hammer in my chest. I needed that letter. I needed it like I needed air. It was my ticket out. My scholarship got me here, but his letter would get me out of here. Out of my past.

All I had to do was spy on his daughter.

He watched me. His eyes were sharp. "I trust you, Ray Collins. And I expect you to keep yourself in check."

A short, laugh escaped me. "Coach, I don't chase after little girls."

"I am hoping to keep it that way," he said, his voice flat.

He took my silence as a yes. "She starts Monday. First team meeting of the season."

He slid a thick, white envelope across the desk. It wasn't sealed. I could see the green edges of bills inside.

My hand moved before my brain could stop it. I picked it up. It was heavy.

He gave a single, firm nod and flicked his hand toward the door. "This stays between us. Now get out. I've got game plans to work on."

"Yes, sir."

I stood up, the envelope feeling like a brick in my hand. I opened the door and stepped back into the bright, noisy hallway of the athletics building.

My teammates were already there, leaning against the wall. Liam and Derek, two of our defensemen, straightened up when they saw me.

"What did the old man want?" Liam asked, a grin spreading across his face. "You in trouble again, Captain?"

I shoved the envelope deep into my jacket pocket. I forced my own grin, the easy, cocky one I wore like my jersey. "Nah. Just stroking my ego. Telling me I'm the best player he's ever had. You know, the usual."

Liam snorted and shoved my shoulder. "Yeah, right. Your head's gonna get so big your helmet won't fit."

Derek launched into a story about a pro scout he'd heard was coming to our next game. The conversation swerved away from me, just like I'd planned.

I walked with them toward the locker room, laughing at the right times, all I could feel was the weight in my pocket. It wasn't just money.

It was a key. A key to my future, handed to me by a man who had just asked me to lie.

And the girl in the photograph, the one with the laughing eyes and the swinging hair... she had no idea her life was now a part of my deal.

I had sold my peace for five hundred dollars and a piece of paper. And Monday, I would start my new job.

Chapter Two: You Were Saying?

Riley

I had done exactly one thing in my entire life without my father's approval, and I was determined not to mess it up.

Figure skating.

It was my secret rebellion, planned and saved for in silence. While my father graded papers and muttered about "frivolous pursuits," I watched old Olympic routines. He wanted debate team, honor society, a direct path to law school.

I wanted the ice.

For two years, I trained in secret at the public rink across town. I paid for lessons with money I saved from tutoring kids in calculus, a fact he never knew. I auditioned for the university's skating team without telling him, and I didn't say a word until the acceptance letter was in my hand.

Today was my first official day.

"Excuse me, sorry."

I squeezed through the crowd clogging the hallway outside Thompson Arena, my gym bag thumping against my leg.

The noise from inside was a physical thing, a deep roar that vibrated in my chest. I should have been heading to the figure skaters' locker room for orientation, but I'd promised Marvel I'd catch the end of his game.

Falcons versus Eagles. The big rivalry. My boyfriend had been talking about this game for weeks.

Five minutes, I told myself. Then I'd run.

I pushed through the heavy double doors just as the sound exploded into a deafening cheer.

Good. The game was still on.

My eyes flew to the scoreboard. Falcons 4, Eagles 3. Four minutes left.

"Marvel!" I whispered, scanning the ice for his number-22.

"Riley?"

My stomach flipped over.

Three rows down, arms crossed over his chest, eyes locked on the game, stood my father.

"Dad?" I made my way down the concrete steps, forcing a smile that felt too bright. "You're here?"

Of course he was here. He was the Falcons' head coach. This was his life. I felt stupid for not expecting him.

He didn't smile. Just gave me a brief, business-like nod before turning his attention back to the ice.

I let out a quiet breath and looked for Marvel.

There he was. Number 22, moving with a grace that always surprised me. Fast, smooth, completely in control. He cut left, dodged a defender, and I lifted my phone. I had to get a picture.

I framed the shot just as he pulled his stick back, every muscle tight and ready.

Then someone crashed into the frame.

Number 17.

The Falcons' captain came out of nowhere. His stick snapped forward, and with one clean, ruthless move, he stole the puck right from Marvel's control. One second Marvel had it. The next, he was stumbling, off-balance, as number 17 blew past him.

I lowered my phone, my breath catching in my throat.

He moved like a storm. Aggressive.

Unstoppable. His own teammates seemed to clear a path for him as he charged the Eagles' goal. The goalie crouched, but it was too late.

The crack of the puck hitting the net was sharp and final.

The arena erupted.

Falcons 5, Eagles 3.

When the buzzer sounded a minute later, it was over. The Falcons swarmed their captain, lifting him onto their shoulders. The crowd was chanting, shaking the old rafters.

"Collins! Collins! Collins!"

Ray Collins.

My father's favorite. The golden boy.

As if he felt me staring, he turned his head where he sat on his teammates' shoulders. His gaze, dark and intense, found mine across the crowded bleachers. It held for one second. Two.

I looked away first, a hot spark of irritation flaring in my chest. There was something about the way he soaked in the worship, like it was his birthright, that grated on me.

Too arrogant.

When I looked back toward the visitors' bench, the Eagles were already filing off the ice, heads down.

Oh, no. Marvel.

"Ignore the final score," my father said beside me, a note of pure satisfaction in his voice. "That was championship-level hockey."

"Marvel played well, too," I murmured, already gathering my bag.

My father started talking about defensive strategy, but I wasn't listening. Marvel hated losing. He'd be dissecting every mistake, furious with himself.

I needed to find him.

"I'll meet you for dinner later," I said, cutting him off gently. He just nodded, his mind already on his winning team.

The visiting team's locker room was down a narrow, damp-smelling hallway on the east side of the arena. I'd been here before. Marvel always came out this way.

I waited outside the heavy door, shifting my weight from foot to foot, practicing my lines in my head.

It's one game. You were amazing. That goal in the second period was perfect. Next time.

The door finally swung open.

A player stepped out, still in full gear, his helmet on. Relief washed through me.

"Hey," I said softly, taking a step closer. "You okay?"

He didn't answer. Just stood there, his back to me.

"I know you're upset, but you played so well tonight," I continued. The words tumbled out in a rush. "That breakaway in the second period? I thought for sure you had it." I reached out and touched his arm. "And you don't have to measure yourself against their captain. You're better than him anyway."

He went completely still.

"Better than who?"

A deep, unfamiliar voice answered. It wasn't Marvel's.

I watched, my heart freezing, as he turned slowly. He lifted his helmet off in one smooth motion.

Dark hair, damp with sweat. A sharp jaw. Eyes that weren't Marvel's warm brown, but a piercing, cool gray.

Ray Collins.

My hand snapped back from his arm like I'd been burned. I stumbled back a step, my fingers knotting together.

He just looked down at me, that intense gaze taking in my shock, my embarrassment. A faint, unreadable smile touched his lips.

"You were saying?" he asked, his voice a low rumble.

Humiliation burned my cheeks, quickly followed by a wave of pure annoyance. I hated that I'd been caught off guard. I hated the way he was looking at me, like I was a funny little puzzle. I opened my mouth, ready to tell him exactly what I thought of arrogant hockey players who eavesdropped, when the Falcons' locker room door burst open behind him.

Laughter and the smell of sweat spilled into the hall. Three of his teammates, still in their gear, piled out. One of them, a guy with a buzz cut, spotted me and grinned.

"Whoa! Aren't you Riley?" Buzz Cut said, slinging an arm around Ray Collins's shoulders. "Coach Hartwell's daughter, right? Saw you in the stands."

Another player, taller, chimed in. "Aren't you being unfair? You're our coach's kid. Shouldn't you be, I dunno, cheering for us?"

All their eyes were on me. I felt like a bug under a glass. I tucked a strand of hair behind my ear, forcing my voice to be calm. "I might be the coach's daughter," I said, looking at the taller player. "But I'm not officially supporting any hockey team."

It was a stupid, defensive thing to say, but I couldn't take it back.

Ray Collins hadn't moved. He was just watching me, that same analyzing look on his face, as if my every reaction was a play he was studying.

"Riley."

The new voice was tight. Strained. I knew it well.

I turned.

There, a few feet away, his gear bag hanging from one hand and his face a mask of cold, clean anger, stood Marvel. My boyfriend.

His eyes moved from my flushed face, to Ray Collins standing so close to me, to Ray Collins's smirking friends.

The silence in the hallway was suddenly very, very loud.

Chapter Three: I need to find her

Riley's Pov

Marvel," I said, the word coming out as a relieved sigh.

He didn't smile. His eyes, usually so warm when they landed on me, were hard. "What's going on?"

"I was looking for you. I came down to... I saw the end of the game." I took a step toward him, wanting to bridge the gap, to get us away from this audience.

"Got lost, did you?" Ray Collins's voice cut through the tension, deceptively mild. "Visitor's room is down the other hall, Hartwell."

The use of my last name, my father's name, in that tone, felt like a deliberate provocation. Marvel's jaw tightened.

Buzzcut chuckled. "She was just telling us how she doesn't support any team, Cap. Neutral party."

I saw the misunderstanding solidify in Marvel's eyes. He thought I'd been chatting with them. With Ray Collins.

"I was waiting for you," I said to Marvel, emphasizing the last word.

But the damage was done. The pride of a losing player, the presence of a rival who seemed to dominate every space he entered, and the girlfriend caught in the middle of it all created a perfect, toxic cocktail.

Marvel gave a short, sharp nod. "Yeah. I see that. Let's go." He turned and started walking, not waiting for me.

I shot one last glance at the group by the locker room. Ray Collins's smirk was gone, replaced by an unreadable, analytical expression. He gave me a slow, almost imperceptible once-over.

Then he turned, shouldering past his teammates with a muttered, "Shower's getting cold," and led them back through the door, leaving me alone.

*******

Ray Collins

The silence in the hallway after they left was louder than the roar of the game had been.

My guys were still buzzing, replaying the winning goal, but the noise felt distant, muffled. All I could see was the back of Riley's head as she followed Martinez down the dim corridor.

"You okay, Cap?" Liam clapped me on the shoulder, his grin fading. "You look like you just took a puck to the teeth."

"I'm fine," I said, my voice coming out flat. "Just tired."

It was a lie. I wasn't tired. I was wired, but not from the win. My skin felt too tight. The image of her face, first soft with concern, then sharp with annoyance was stuck behind my eyes.

Better than him anyway.

Why did those words hook under my ribs like that? She didn't know me. She'd decided who I was from the cheap seats. So why did I give a damn what she thought?

My friends' chatter about the game stats faded into a meaningless hum. I was only half-listening as we filed back into the steam-filled chaos of the locker room.

Guys were laughing, shouting, music blasting from a speaker. Normal victory chaos. I went through the motions: peeling off my sweat-soaked gear, nodding at the right times, but my mind was somewhere else.

It was down that other hallway. Were they arguing? Was she touching his arm for real this time, saying all the right, soothing things? Was he believing her? The thought made my jaw clench.

And why the hell was I thinking about it? This was exactly the kind of "distraction" Hartwell had hired me to monitor. Not to get tangled in.

"Earth to Ray Collins!" A hand waved in front of my face.

I blinked. Liam was standing in front of me, already in his street clothes, eyebrows raised. The locker room was almost empty.

"You've been staring at that locker for five minutes, man. You concussed or something?"

"No," I grunted, finally turning to grab my towel. "Just thinking."

"Well, stop thinking and start moving. Union party at The Rink Bar. You in?"

The Union Party. A stupid tradition. Whenever Falcons or Eagles won a head-to-head, both teams were expected to show up at the same off-campus bar. It was supposed to foster cooperation. Usually, it fostered drunken shouting and the occasional fistfight.

"Not really feeling it," I said, heading for the showers.

"Since when?" Liam called after me. "You're the captain. It's basically mandatory."

The hot water did little to clear my head. Riley's schedule, the one Hartwell had texted me, flashed in my mind. Psychology 305. Mon/Wed/Fri, 10 AM. This was her world. Class, the library, her skates. Not hockey parties.

But Martinez was a hockey player. A star for the Eagles. He'd be at that party. And if he was going...

She'd be there, too. Trying to smooth things over. Playing the supportive girlfriend in a room full of people who'd just watched him lose.

A fresh, sharp curiosity cut through me. What was she like in that setting? Was her cool composure real, or just for show?

Hartwell's voice slithered into my thoughts: "She does not understand what these boys want from her."

My job was to watch. To be there. This wasn't curiosity; it was duty.

I turned the water off with a hard twist.

"Change of plans," I said to Liam as I strode back to my locker, dripping. "I'll go."