The last thing I remembered was the stench of stale beer and damp asphalt, then the crunch of my own bones.
My best friend Becca, my sorority little sister, stood by, pointing, her face a mask of cold satisfaction.
She had used my ID, my photos, my name for her own sinister schemes, and it led to my brutal death in that alley by loan sharks.
Killed simply because I was too trusting, too kind, too naive to see her for what she truly was.
But then, I woke up.
The scent of lavender laundry detergent filled the air, my body was whole, no pain, no blood.
And then I heard it – the soft click of a phone camera.
Becca, standing in my doorway, phone aimed at me, just like the day it all began.
This time, there would be no pity, no forgiveness.
This time, I was ready.
The last thing I remembered was the stench of stale beer and damp asphalt.
Then the crunch of bone. My own.
The loan sharks didn' t care that I didn't know anything about a payday loan. They just saw my face, the one on the ID Becca had used, and they wanted their money.
Becca, my sorority little sister, stood by, pointing. Her face, the one she hated because of the purplish birthmark, was a mask of cold satisfaction. "That's her," she' d said. "That's Chloe."
They beat me to death in that alley. All because Becca used my photos to catfish a bouncer, used my ID to get an abortion, and used my name to fund a cosmetic surgery consultation she never got to have.
Now, I was awake.
The air smelled like lavender laundry detergent and the cheap vanilla plug-in from our dorm suite. My body was whole. No pain. No blood.
I looked at my hands. They were clean, nails perfectly manicured in a pale pink.
Then I heard it. The soft, almost silent click of a phone camera.
The sound that started it all.
I turned slowly. Becca stood in the doorway of my bedroom, her phone aimed at me. I had just stepped out of the shower, a towel wrapped around my body.
This was it. The moment I confronted her in my first life. The moment I chose pity over instinct.
She saw that I' d noticed. Her eyes widened in fake panic.
"Chloe! I... I'm so sorry. You just looked so pretty, like a model. I just wanted a picture..."
Her voice was a practiced, trembling whisper.
I didn't say a word. I just stared at her, the memory of the alley, the pain, the betrayal, burning cold in my chest.
My silence unnerved her. The fake tears started to well up.
"I'll delete it, I swear! Please don't be mad."
Just like before, the door to the suite burst open. Megan and Lauren, my other sorority sisters, rushed in. They were always ready to play savior to Becca' s damsel.
"Chloe, what's going on?" Megan demanded, her eyes immediately finding Becca' s tear-streaked face. "Why is she crying?"
Lauren put an arm around Becca. "Did you say something to her? You know how sensitive she is."
Becca sniffled, hiding her face in Lauren's shoulder. "I just... I took a picture of her. She looked so beautiful, and I wanted to remember it. I know it was wrong."
She was a master. She confessed to a small, forgivable sin to hide the bigger, darker one.
"A picture?" Megan scoffed, turning on me. "That's it? You're going to bully her over a stupid picture? God, Chloe, she looks up to you. She' s on scholarship, she has it hard enough without you being a mean girl."
In my first life, their accusations worked. I felt guilty. I was the popular, pretty, comfortable one. They made me feel like a monster for being upset about a violation of my privacy. I forgave her. And it got me killed.
This time, there would be no forgiveness. Only a reckoning.
I let the silence hang in the air for a moment, watching Megan and Lauren glare at me, their self-righteousness practically radiating off them. I let Becca sob into Lauren' s shirt, milking the moment for all it was worth.
Then, I softened my expression. I let out a long, theatrical sigh.
"You're right," I said, my voice dripping with false remorse. "I'm sorry, Becca. I overreacted."
The change was immediate. Megan' s face relaxed. Lauren gave me a small, approving nod. Becca peeked out from her hiding spot, her eyes still wet but now holding a flicker of triumph.
"It's just... I'm private," I continued, looking at the floor. "It startled me. But I know you didn't mean any harm."
"Of course I didn't," Becca mumbled. "I would never."
I walked over to her, my hand outstretched. "Come on. Let me see the phone. We'll delete it together, and it'll be forgotten. No big deal."
This was the critical part. In my past life, I just told her to delete it and trusted her. This time, I needed proof. I needed her phone.
She hesitated for a split second, a flash of pure panic in her eyes before she masked it. She couldn't refuse without looking suspicious. Reluctantly, she unlocked her phone and handed it to me.
"See? It's the only one," she said, her voice a little too high.
I navigated to her photo gallery. The picture of me in a towel was right there. I made a show of holding down the delete button. "Gone," I said with a smile.
But I didn't give the phone back.
"Let me just check your recently deleted folder," I said casually. "You know how these iPhones are."
While her back was turned, comforted by her two cronies, my fingers flew across the screen. I wasn't looking for photos. I was looking for notifications. And there they were, a string of them at the top of her screen.
A dating app. Messages from a user named "T-Bone."
'Damn girl, you are a knockout.'
'When can I see you for real? Don' t leave me hanging.'
'That pic you sent last night... WOW.'
My blood ran cold, but my face remained a mask of friendly concern. I swiped the notifications away and handed the phone back to her.
"All clear," I said cheerfully. "See? All good. Let's forget this ever happened."
Becca snatched the phone back, her relief obvious. Megan and Lauren shot me one last dirty look before leading Becca out of my room, cooing about getting froyo to make her feel better.
The moment the door closed, my smile vanished. The first part of my plan was in motion.
That evening, the sorority was having a formal. It was the perfect opportunity. I set up my phone on a tripod, my makeup spread out on my desk. I went live on TikTok.
"Hey guys! GRWM for my sorority formal!" I chirped, starting with my foundation.
The comments started rolling in. I answered questions about my dress, my major, the party theme. I made sure to tag the university, Kappa Alpha Theta, and use a dozen local hashtags. I knew my audience.
Then, a planted question from one of my real friends popped up, just as we' d planned.
'Are you going with anyone tonight Chloe? U have a bf?'
I laughed, dabbing concealer under my eyes. "Oh my god, no. So single. I've actually never even been on a dating app. I'm too shy for that, can you believe it? I'm hoping to meet someone cute tonight the old-fashioned way."
I let the statement hang there. Simple, direct, and completely deniable. I wasn't accusing anyone of anything. I was just a single girl, getting ready for a party.
But I knew who was watching. T-Bone. The bouncer from the local dive bar. The kind of guy who would definitely follow university hashtags, looking for his next hookup.
He would see my face, hear my voice. He would know I wasn't the girl he'd been texting. He would know he' d been played.
And he would be very, very angry.